Welcome to Gaia! ::


Seeker

(Wasn't quite sure who to do, John W. Wells's or Leonis's story. If I've done the wrong one, forgive me and I can do Leonis's also. sweatdrop And if my submission is to late, please disregard it. heart )

Author and Title: John W. Wells, Inside

1. Style Rating: 4 - It seemed to flow well, and each sentence left me wanting to read the next.

2. Narrative Rating: 3.5 - I read it a couple times and really got into it the second or third. The only problem I had at first was telling the difference between the rat's thoughts and the humans talking.

3. Characters Rating: 4 - I would find it very hard to put feeling and character into a rat. It was done very well in this story, and I commend you for that.

4. Grammar, Spelling, and Punctuation Rating: 4 - There was only one thing that I saw, and you left out a period... I think... I can't remember where it was, but I'll try and find it...

5. Plot Rating: 4 - Very creative. I haven't seen anything like it, and really enjoyed reading it.

6. Over-all Impression Rating: 4 - The piece was very creative. The only thing I would've thought to add you had already included!

I was going to say what the rat was being trained for... but remembered this part.
Quote:
I?m going to start training him. You know, I wonder if we?ll ever really reach the point where we can make a rat that, say, can do arithmetic.

Seeker

Author: Enadariel
Title: Today I Died For It
Contest Assignment Title: Free Choice
Submission Genre: Short Story
Submission Being Reviewed: John W. Wells, Inside

((Don't judge this part; Like Leonis, I'd like to put a little background information in here...))
I wrote this a couple years ago, when the planes hit the World Trade Center towers in America. I apologize if this seems baised, but I didn't think it would or intend for it to.


It started out as a normal day. I woke up, showered, and went to my work as a bank teller. It was a slow day with only a few customers, an elderly lady who needed to check on her savings account and a young mother whose little boy was crying the throughout our whole transaction.

I heard a small, familiar beep. It was my pager. I looked over at Lina, the other bank teller on duty, with a wild eyed stare. She nodded toward the door, promising to cover for me. As a volunteer fire-fighter, the other workers were used to me vanishing occasionally.

At the firehouse, I met with some of the other volunteers. Instead of looking as they always did, there was an odd aura about the firehouse. Grown men walked around with looks of pure horror, and some shied from my glances with wounded pride. I caught sight of a television in the corner of the garage. My mind went numb. The... the... The... Trade Center Tower... I went through the rest of my pre-fire drill duties in a daze. The emotions swelling up in my heart were of immense sadness and terror. Us? In America? How? Why?

Several anxiety filled moments later, my group was at the edge of the crash site, or as close as the general public was allowed to go. I walked, or stumbled, to the scene of the crash. It had been a beautiful day this morning when I had driven to the bank. Now, the New York air was filled with dust, ash, and smoke.

Several fire-fighters were selected to go into the tower to search for survivors. Before I could react, I was shoved towards a group of fire-men ready to enter the tower.

Someone screamed. Then, the clamor was taken up by the congregation of hundreds as a second plane crashed into the remaining tower. I fell to the ground and pounded my fist into the dirt. My throat tightened, and I let the tears fall unashamedly. I felt a hand on my shoulder, and a voice bellowed into my ear, screaming something about a rescue party. I was forced to my feet. "Is there no time to morn for the dead?" A voice, barely heard, voiced my thoughts exactly. But now was a time for action. I joined a group of fire-fighters headed towards the towers.

Once inside the towers, I looked around, not knowing where to begin. As I climbed higher into the tower, all I could do was shake my head. There was no-one in here stupid enough to remain. The man I was partnered with agreed. We were just about to turn back when a feeble cry for help resounded through the debris scattered hall. We rushed up a set of steps to find a man trapped beneath a scattering of steel beams. Muscles strained, and he was free. Miraculously uninjured, he hurried out of the building without a word of thanks. I shook my head and continued upward.

As we worked out way upward, the building shifted and swayed in the wind. Another cry for help rang through the air, and we turned a corner to find a woman pined under a metal filing cabinet. The downed plaster and supports of the ceiling above completed her entrapment. A few minutes later, my companion was carrying the half paralyzed woman toward the stairways. The look on her face I would never forget- a look of gratitude intertwined with raw fear.

As I continued my way up, the swaying of the tower became much worse. The building lurched and heaved with every hesitant step I took. Twice I was thrown against the ground, the wind knocked out of me. Wreckage was strewn about, and many of the metal support beams had melted or were in severe disrepair as a result of the plane's crash.

I heard the first cries of help that had reached my ears in a while. They were almost drowned out by the whistling of the wind, and for a moment I assumed I was hearing things. The thought of safety on the ground below called me, but I picked my way toward a debris strewn stairwell. I couldn't ignore the rule that had been pounded into my head in the days of my early training- never leave a man behind.

The next floor was so bad that I could hardly pick my way through it. The rubble was so intense that I was literally crawling on my hands and knees most of the way through. I rounded a corner and stared in shock. The office complex and much of the wall were gone. After seeing that damage, I was beginning to wonder if I had imagined the cries for help, but further down the hall, a pleading sob came forth once again. I found a young man curled up in one of the only remaining corners on the floor. He was staring straight ahead at apparently nothing, and many of the ceiling tiles had fallen all around him. I touched him on the shoulder and he jumped, snarling something I couldn't understand. He sprung toward the hallway, and dropped to his hands and knees as quickly as he could, skirting under the debris in the hallway. I shook my head in amazement. Why in the world had he... Suddenly, the building lurched and sent me spiraling towards the gaping hole in the wall. The building buckled violently, and I said I quick prayer for both mine and that man's safety. The building lurched again and shot me closer to the gaping hole.

I managed to grab onto a desk which was not yet overturned. Once again on my feet, I walked as best I could away from the wall. I heard frantic cries for help and realized that I could never get all the people trapped out in time. At this point, I doubted I could get myself out in time. The cries became more frantic, and I winced as they ended in a blood-chilling scream followed by a far away rumble. Floors up, the supports had finally started to collapse. The rumbling sounded again, and again, and I knew that the floors had been collapsing on one another as I’d worked my way up the building. The falling debris would soon be upon me; it was no use running.

I write this now hoping that someone will read my story and pick up my failing torch. Yesterday I lived in freedom. Today I will die for it.
Enadariel: Thank you for your comments! I've sent you a PM discussing them, and made a bit of an editorial correction to my story in response to them.

Dedicated Raider

Thank you all for your entries and Peer Reviews. This contest is closed, and you have our gratitude for making it a Premiere Success.

PLEASE NOTE: The link for the 2nd (now current) Contest is: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4989468&start=0&postdays=0&postorder=asc&highlight=

Decisions will be made, announcements posted, and prizes awarded as soon as possible (hopefully by late Sunday night).

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Well, once again we have one piece that was not reviewed, along with the first. We are waiting for cassandra to do the last submission, and ranjir has been kind enough to not expect a review this go around.

I apologize in advance should cassandra not get hers in. We are open to suggestions for improving the Peer Review criteria.

Hopefully things will go smoother in the Current Contest, and thank you all again for your patience.

Sqarr's computer is up and (currently) down but he is working on it and says that we can expect a final conclusion (yes, I know...) by tomorrow (Friday) night at the latest.

Feel free to visit the Headquartes thread for on-going conversation.

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
UPDATE: Sqarr and I have conferred and decided that we will post our reviews within about 4 hours, along with decisions and awards.

He is currently fixing his computer and will then get to work. If there are any further delays you may all flay us at will with wet noodles!

This will not happen again. Future contests will adhere to posted time lines.

This first contest was a learning experience for us and we believe we have a better understanding of the time it takes to review, post, and tend to other duties. Details will be posted as an edit in the Current Contest thread.

Updates still need ing to be done include links (Head Graphics, closed contest threads, and other pertinent links as we find them.

Thank you AGAIN for your on-going patience and support!

We hope the prizes in the Current Contest will attract submissions, including regulars and new entrants alike.

Warm regards...

The Foundation Staff.

Please note: I had a message from Rose apologizing for her time constraints. She hopes to be a support in terms of entering her own submissions and doing Peer Reviews as needed.

THANK YOU ROSE!

Anyone interested in helping up with formal judging and decisions, please PM either Sqarr or myself.
accidental post redface

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Formally unnecessary, if anyone has the time to do a Peer Review of ranjir's piece it would be appreciated.
Judging "Edge of the World [Original Version]," by pingpong867
--[ Style ] I'm reviewing this version of this piece because it feels better than the rewrite. Punctuation and grammar were good. Having a fairly negative view of the world at large myself, I found it easy enough to identify with some of the commentary in this, so it was presented in a manner that felt right for me. I am quite particular, so it probably won't suit everyone. (3 - Average)

--[ Narrative ] While I am not suicidal and don't feel the world's better off with me in it, I agree with much of what is said here about state of our species. The yellow tape remark is poignant to a degree, but could be strengthened. I'm not sure how, though. Probably something to do with simplification. Unfortunately, much of the narrative is bland and not very deep in the emotional department, so my strings weren't necessarily tugged. What is being said is good enough, but its delivery could be deeper. (3 - Average)

--[ Characters ] Characters were consistent insofar as they existed. The narrator was consistent. The change of heart at the end didn't seem like much of a change of character or perception, though. (2 - Fair)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Good usage here, except for a little over-use of commas. (3 - Average)

--[ Plot | Originality ] People rightfully tend to shy away from arrogant commentaries, but I’ve found humility is redundant these days. In certain terms, anyway. It all depends what you’re being arrogant or forceful about. If it’s something as abstract and subjective as abortion, nobody has any business being arrogant. But when it’s obvious stuff like some guy being a lying jack-a** and other lying jackasses supporting him, it’s perfectly alright to be forceful. If not you, then who will do something about it? Then again, there’s too much talk about how Bush needs to go and how our society’s a Neanderthal’s armpit, but nobody does ******** about it. So what good is it to continue spouting rhetoric that doesn’t incite anyone to fix anything? I could write an essay. There’s nothing original about societal criticism, as much as I agree with it. I commend you on saying it, but at the same time I feel conflicted about the lack of action anyone’s taking about it. (2 - Fair)

--[ Overall ] An uninteresting narrative caused by a lack of emotional depth hindered what could have otherwise been a piece with meaning. Unfortunately, the meaning's been played out and people are bored with hearing about it without action being taken to fix it. I think Bush is in power because people are looking for a rosy picture of life, even if it's an excruciatingly obvious lie. The negative view, no matter how truthful, no longer moves the world at large. Sure, it moves those of us who still give a ******** about what kind of street corner our children will have to live on, but we are becoming a fringe because those we allow to have power are shoving us aside. (2 - Fair)
Judging "her tether," by Little Teacup Storm
--[ Overall ] I don't have the personal background that would make me comfortable in critiquing this piece. My inclinations are not poetic and this piece is far more complex than I can feel. Mahayr's opinions will have to carry it. (4 – Above Average)
Judging "Culture and Parade," by Cassandra022
--[ Style ] This felt good. The direction and thought processes were very believable for the most part. There was only a bit at the end that was too mechanical, like the author was no longer feeling the situation and was just describing it because it had to be described. (3 - Average)

--[ Narrative ] Again, this was good, but eventually fell away. Consistency of feeling would have helped this greatly. The childishness was just not carried all the way. (3 - Average)

--[ Characters ] I feel much the same as this child most any day I have to leave the house and be surrounded by crowds of people I have no connection to. Despite a mechanical presentation through part of this story, I felt the characters were believable. I've seen that ignorant, careless mother a thousand times, in a thousand similar situations. And I've been that child. My own mother was much better about that sort of thing, though. (4 – Above Average)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Spelling was very poor in this piece. Punctuation was fair. (1 - Poor)

--[ Plot | Originality ] Daria comes to mind. I'm sure many of you know and love the character that was created for the Beavis & Butthead spew, but ended up having her own much more intelligent and worthwhile series. Despite being the kind of loner story that is common nowadays, this piece set itself apart by being in a unique setting, with different characters than I'm used to seeing in this sort of story. (4 – Above Average)

--[ Overall ] I’ve been to Polish celebrations and bazaars and parades and theater productions. In Montreal, at least, I’ve come to find them to be excruciatingly tacky. Compared to some of the things Montreal’s Russian communities are doing, there’s just no excuse. I’ve seen completely unrelated stores and businesses actually invite Russian artisans to set up tables in their stores, just because what they’re selling is so finely crafted or at least appealing to the eyes. I have not, however, seen any Polish artisans at all, except for dinky crap being peddled at bazaars. Now, I have nothing against the Polish people. It’s just I haven’t seen much good from their community in Montreal. There is a little meat shop that has incredible hand-made kelbasa, made fresh every day [the best time to get it is before eight on Saturday morning, when you can see it being carried out of the smoke room and put up on hooks to dry] that also sells the best sauerkraut and a few other good things [mostly meat], but that isn’t saying much. I feel this child’s pain not only as a fellow antisocialite, but also because I’m not big on what I’ve seen Poland give my home town. Man, do I miss Saint Viateur’s bagels with slices of Ronnie’s kelbasa, mayo, fresh cheese and tomato, though. Good story. Believable setting and characters, only off-set by poor spelling and something of a mechanical delivery. Strong potential, I think. (3 - Average)
Judging "Tears of Heartbreak," by Misty Amethyst
--[ Overall ] There's something to be said for brevity. I think the author took a risk by not filling out the word limit, which is good. I also think copyrights are completely unnecessary in this kind of setting, especially with something so small. That said, there's no accounting for some things. Unlike Mahayr, as I said, I am not nearly inclined to poetry, but I did get some sense of emotion from this one. It's not Patrick Woodroffe's "Hallelujah Anyway" [which touched me mostly because it's so incredibly illustrated], but it works well enough on its own merits. But then, I don't have much of a developed opinion in this regard. (3 - Average)
Judging "Hell Masked," by Damiascutlass
--[ Style ] I felt this piece aptly overbearing, as I suppose it should be, given the context. Perhaps the melodrama could have been a little lighter, but then the feeling of the aristocratic reenactment would have probably been lost. The effect is good, though I wouldn't have written it the same, myself. I'm giving good marks for fitting the context so well. (4 – Above Average)

--[ Narrative ] Certain phrases used here didn't feel natural. I attribute this to the aristocratic airs and pomp festering in the setting, which works, since this isn't a first-person piece. (3 - Average)

--[ Characters ] Most of the speech is horribly forced and overly calculated, as is befitting the context. I personally prefer natural speech, but I can't expect it here. Unfortunately, this doesn't line up entirely with what I know of aristocratic lingo despite a good attempt at emulating it. The characters, themselves, come across well enough. (3 - Average)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Punctuation is strong here. Grammar is spotty. (2 - Fair)

--[ Plot | Originality ] I don't personally care for rape fantasies, so it doesn't appeal to me too well. I'm no stranger to the predatory male instincts, but I found the girl to be too easily misled. I expect more from the female species, I guess. If this were a straight aristocratic yarn, I would have to say it were average. But since it deals with more modern scum living out an ugly bit of history [vive la revolution] there's something just that much more sickening about it. (4 – Above Average)

--[ Overall ] Some small technical difficulties barely keep this from being exceptional. It's not my cup of tea, but I'm sure a young, fetishistic audience like many of the depraved teens on Gaia would eat it up like candy anyway. The author did a good job in thinking up something a little different [though I detect hints of some of the elements that people like their vampire stories to have] and delivering it with a good deal of class. The subject matter is quite respectably mature, but ends up coming off a little bit like a Harlequin thing. (3 - Average)
Judging "The Night Before Christmas," by Glitch Makoto
--[ Style ] I see this as more of a story told in rhyme than an actual poem, so I'll treat as such. The premise is humorous, but is a little lacking in the kind of wild rhyming ingenuity that would have made this leave a really lasting impression, as KoRn's "Jingle Balls" [or whatever it's really called; I never found out the name] does. (3 - Average)

--[ Narrative ] It's fun, it moves the reader along at a high pace, it has a good moral. High marks for a good, snappy ride. (4 – Above Average)

--[ Characters ] I can just see the narrator slinking around like Sly Cooper, the thieving raccoon and Santa lives up to his all-seeing reputation, but with a bit of a bad-a** twist. It's kind of one-dimensional, but it works. (3 - Average)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Punctuation's difficult to judge here, but the grammar seemed appropriate enough. The misspelling of "nunchucks" was a little awkward, though. (3 - Average)

--[ Plot | Originality ] The plot's consistent with the characters, though the originality's low. This sort of story is common enough without throwing in everyone's greed for Christmas loot. (2 - Fair)

--[ Overall ] Appropriately themed for the holidays and for the little heathen youth that infests Gaia, I find this little rhyme a fun romp. I think the author had fun writing this, which is very important. Unfortunately, the delivery is just a little short of brilliant. (3 - Average)

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Judging "Only Once," by Mytyl
--[ Style ] Accurate use of first person with consistent tense. While I was left with some unanswered questions and found a few details a bit illogical, the overall style was convincing in itself. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Narrative ] There was a smooth flow to this piece making it easy to read and understand. A good mix of dialogue and description. However, I found the last sentence poorly worded, giving the feeling of being out of sync. (3 - Average)

--[ Characters ] The main character, the assassin, seemed to waver between a tough bravado and the too-soft student, leaving the character overly weak and ineffectual. Her Master was quite god - convincing and strong. (3 - Average)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Very nicely done. I may have made different choices, but we are each our own author and I found the grammar and punctuation accurate, readable, and unobtrusive. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Plot | Originality ] This particular plot has been done too many times to be original. Technically well done, another story about an assassin who is hired to kill someone close is not gripping. (2 - Fair)

--[ Overall ] Despite the overdone plot, this piece was an easy read, technically well done, smooth, consistent, and held my interest. (4 - Above Average)

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
//
//

Join Now

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//