Welcome to Gaia! ::

The New Gaia Alliance for the Mentally Ill

Back to Guilds

A mental illness support guild 

Tags: mental illness, suicide, depression, personality disorder, anxiety 

Reply The New Gaia Alliance for the Mentally Ill
Misconceptions and Fumbling Reactions to Mental Illness

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

She-Lich

PostPosted: Sat Jul 24, 2010 3:21 pm


I'm going to confess up front that I made this thread because I had a strong urge to vent.

I've joined a dating site recently, and I find myself telling more people that I'm mentally ill than I've told in a lifetime. I guess I just feel like I should be up front about that, to weed out the ones who are going to freak out later on when it will be more painful to have them freak out.

Anyway, this one guy goes, "Are you sure you're mentally ill? You seem so normal! And you type so coherently!"

As if mentally ill people can't ******** type. As if we're all talking out loud to ourselves and rocking back and forth and wearing straight jackets.

So I told him, "No, that's a misconception, mentally ill people are like everybody else," and then he apologizes, and I talk about it some more, and he says,

"Let's not talk about this anymore."

Not talk about my life? Sweep it under the rug like it's something inappropriate and ugly? Ugh.

And a telemarketer managed to squeeze the information out of me that I'm mentally ill, and he's like, "Oh, can you read and write?" Like being mentally ill renders me incapable of reading and writing. Ffft.

So, what kind of horrible reactions have you guys gotten when you told someone about your mental illness?

Edit: Oh, would this be better in the Off-Topic subforum? If so, sorry for misposting it here. I was going to delete it and re-post it in the right subforum, but it seems I can't delete my own threads.
PostPosted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 9:44 am


Ahhh! That would be infuriating. After I was diagnosed I had some family start sending me "care packages" and taking to me like I was a little kid. Like I had cancer or something.

I also regularly have the problem of people assuming I don't know what I'm talking about because I'm mentally ill, especially if what I'm saying means they are wrong. They are automatically right because I'm mentally ill.

TheUnendurableRapture
Crew


She-Lich

PostPosted: Sun Jul 25, 2010 3:23 pm


********, that's annoying. My mom and brother do that. They say things like, "Maybe you're hallucinating," or "Maybe it's your schizoaffective disorder acting up," or "Maybe you're just paranoid schizophrenic."
PostPosted: Thu Jul 29, 2010 8:15 am


I'm going to post, here, an on-topic, well-phrased, and thought-out expansion to my last post.

My last post was "Have you guys taken your meds today?" And I may have had an XD or the like included.

There was a double-meaning to this post.

First, it was an on-topic reply, because I, others that I know, (and some of the people in this guild), have likely all been asked that question as a way of ending an argument when another person is annoyed with the argument itself - and I'm not even technically diagnosed with a mental illness or taking a prescription for anything. This is probably the single most infuriating reaction to ever have crossed my path, both as an insulting way to shed doubt on a person's clarity of thought, mental capacity, or ability to function intellectually, and as a way to weasel out of an debate or argument that usually the person asking that question is losing.

Secondly, I did not elaborate thereupon, because (as apparently it was, just not properly) I thought that the sentence itself would be reminiscent of the situation described in the above paragraph and thus be self-explanatory.

And, admittedly, I thought the irony of using the question itself as its own example and explanation was a bit humorous.

I am going to state this here as well:

I am sorry for the way my post may have come across, and will in the future attempt to explain such things.

I am a blunt, usually sarcastic, and sometimes incredibly harsh individual, but I do not post things (even such things as my last post here) as trolling. I am not a troll, and I would not have joined this guild for that purpose.

In the future, those who read my posts should be aware that if it comes across as inflammatory, that is because they are misunderstanding my purpose.

I posted it because it was an on-topic, accurate reply, as a direct answer to the last question in the original post.

"So, what kind of horrible reactions have you guys gotten when you told someone about your mental illness?"

"Have you (guys) taken your meds today?"

That is the worst, most infuriating, and awful reaction that I've ever seen, heard, or of which I've been a subject.

That is all.

Eruandil

Distinct Raider


She-Lich

PostPosted: Thu Jul 29, 2010 3:55 pm


Thank you, Eruandil. I really appreciate the clarification. I think most of all it was the ;D face that set me off. That's not your fault, it's just a face I've had people use when they were trying to get a rise out of me, so that's the association I have with it.
PostPosted: Tue Nov 02, 2010 6:17 pm


She-Lich
I'm going to confess up front that I made this thread because I had a strong urge to vent.

I've joined a dating site recently, and I find myself telling more people that I'm mentally ill than I've told in a lifetime. I guess I just feel like I should be up front about that, to weed out the ones who are going to freak out later on when it will be more painful to have them freak out.

Anyway, this one guy goes, "Are you sure you're mentally ill? You seem so normal! And you type so coherently!"

As if mentally ill people can't ******** type. As if we're all talking out loud to ourselves and rocking back and forth and wearing straight jackets.

So I told him, "No, that's a misconception, mentally ill people are like everybody else," and then he apologizes, and I talk about it some more, and he says,

"Let's not talk about this anymore."

Not talk about my life? Sweep it under the rug like it's something inappropriate and ugly? Ugh.

And a telemarketer managed to squeeze the information out of me that I'm mentally ill, and he's like, "Oh, can you read and write?" Like being mentally ill renders me incapable of reading and writing. Ffft.

So, what kind of horrible reactions have you guys gotten when you told someone about your mental illness?

Edit: Oh, would this be better in the Off-Topic subforum? If so, sorry for misposting it here. I was going to delete it and re-post it in the right subforum, but it seems I can't delete my own threads.


I'm not mentally ill. However I am quite knowledgeable about it and plan to work with the mentally ill.

It pisses me off how society pushes people like you away and avoids you guys as if you are contagious. Honestly, I know many people who are mentally "ill" (if you want to use that term). I don't have a problem with mental illness, and am quite adamant about the treatment of the ill.

Essentially, the key reason why people act that way is ignorance. The media publicizes the dangerously insane and overdramatizes everything. This puts a thought into everybody's head of, "Oh my God, this person is schizo! They're going to kill me and my family!"

Horror movies don't help either with this. And yet, these same people who are influenced by the media give 0% effort to search for truth. All they can tell you about mental illness is what movies say (that's why after "Inception" came out, everybody became an expert on sleep studies all of the sudden. It's not about mental illness, but shows the real influence of our society). And yet with every new psychological movie released, people parrot new facts on a daily basis.

Society avoids that which they cannot explain or what they cannot control. They don't see mental hospitals as facilities to help the mentally disturbed learn to live WITH their illness. They see them as facilities that "lock up the crazies". It sickens me and I hate it. Just because there's something going on in your brain, it doesn't make you any less human.

I sincerely am sorry for the sort of crap you have to put up with. But if you ever need a friend or want to talk, feel free to message me. I'll send you a friend request. smile

Mercenarii
Crew

5,450 Points
  • Signature Look 250
  • Autobiographer 200
  • Person of Interest 200

Prince Darialan

1,200 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
PostPosted: Wed Nov 03, 2010 6:09 am


They really need to make movies or something about people with Schizophenia or some other illness. I mean it wouldn't be that hard to work in a good character with that or any other illness. In fact it might make it quite interesting for people. We already have Monk, but from what all I learned about OCD, it only paints one picture of OCD. Though from what someone with OCD told me, it is done very well.
PostPosted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 7:49 pm


Prince Darialan Love
They really need to make movies or something about people with Schizophenia or some other illness. I mean it wouldn't be that hard to work in a good character with that or any other illness. In fact it might make it quite interesting for people. We already have Monk, but from what all I learned about OCD, it only paints one picture of OCD. Though from what someone with OCD told me, it is done very well.


Actually, a lot of horror movies are made around the premise of insanity, especially schizophrenia. This is what causes the misconceptions about the mental defect. And what causes such rejection of it. The media's influence on our understanding of the world is ridiculous. Notice that after Monk came out as a TV show, nearly EVERYBODY suddenly became OCD?

It's called hypochondriasis (aka Medical Student Syndrome). It basically is when you study a disease or hear about it, and start to believe you have it because you exhibit one or two symptoms and blow it out of proportion. The media basically causes the same reaction in the mass populace.

Inception- Everybody becomes an expert on sleep studies.
Monk- Everybody becomes Obsessive-Compulsive.
Lie to Me- Everybody becomes an expert on body language.
CSI (and other murder mystery shows)- Everybody becomes an expert killer.
Law & Order- Everybody becomes a lawyer.

These are just a few examples. I think that we need less movies with the premises of mental illness, because they will dramatize the reality of it to appeal to the viewers. This will cause even further misconceptions in the peoples' minds.

Mercenarii
Crew

5,450 Points
  • Signature Look 250
  • Autobiographer 200
  • Person of Interest 200

Trash Angel

6,300 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Window Shopper 100
  • Cart Raider 100
PostPosted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 8:13 pm


i wish i could tell ppl like you can,being so strong minded and self confident must be great,i used to be like that, but ever since ppl shunned me for it in sixh grade iv been to scared to. lol and i hate myself so much for that XD
PostPosted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 9:21 pm


have youever read anything by Nancy Mairs? I'd suggest her Essay, Disability, which about exactly this kind of thing.

anywho, I'll respond to this more in depth in just a little bit, I'm multitasking (something I'm only just learning how to do), and feeling extremely upset right now... it's hard for me to focus.

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200

Chieftain Twilight

Loyal Rogue

14,550 Points
  • Full closet 200
  • Tested Practitioner 250
  • Elocutionist 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 28, 2010 10:45 pm


I've been diagnosed with Paranoid Schitzophrenia, and almost anyone I tell thinks poorly of me. it's often used as an excuse for my different behavior, and my friends joke about how little sense I make, just because my thought patterns are contrary to theres.

and then there are all the folks who suddenly become afraid of me when they hear that I refuse to take medications. they start telling me about all the dangers I could pose to the people I love and care about, and to myself. like even though I went through 5 years of life just since the diagnosis without Meds and am doing fine I could snap at any moment and just randomly kill someone.

and all the people who think that my beliefs in certain conspiracies, and the conspiracy theories I have, are all just symptoms of my madness; delusions and paranoia that "the voices" are telling me, hyped up by my loose imagination.

I'll admit, I realy do have halluscinations, and I realy am paranoid, and I have become hyteric enough to assault my close Friends. but the halluscinations only happen when I am extremely stressed out, the hysteric assaults have only happened when I was at least as stressed out as the halluscination AND drunk off my a** (and they have since stopped happening), and just because I'm paranoid doesn't mean I'm mistaken.

the world has always treated those who are different like they are sick and dangerous. that's nothing new. it's just a tool, it's politics. the system fears us, because we are a threat. we aren't as easily controlled as the "sane" population, so they have to develop measures to keep us in line. we can either fit in, or be ostracized.

that's just the way it is.
Reply
The New Gaia Alliance for the Mentally Ill

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
//
//

// //

Have an account? Login Now!

//
//